I decided to steal this chart from some misc. message board.

*Goes without saying, but: only superhero films*

Best Picture: Masters of the Universe
Runner-Up: Superman II (or IV if I had to pick a second)

Best Actor (Hero): Christopher Reeve - Superman :'(
Runner-Up: Vincent D'Onofrio - Thor

Best Actor (Villain): Frank Langella - Skeletor
Runner-Up (tie): Raul Julia - M. Bison, a lot of people - Jason fucking Vorhees

Best Actress: Uma Thurman - Beatrix Kiddo (because I can't think of a real one)
Runner-Up: Helen Slater - Supergirl

Best Comic Relief Actor or Actress: Otis - Superman I-II
Runner-Up: Gwildor - Masters of the Universe

Best Musical Score: Danny Elfman - Batman

Best Direction: Tim Burton - Batman Returns
Runner-Up:

Best Screenplay: Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (complete script - great read)
Runner-Up: I don't know, maybe Batman Begins or something...

Best Special FX: Matrix Revolutions
Runner-Up: Dark City

Best Fight Sequences: Catwoman vs. Clayface! (upset! Boooooooo!!!)

Best Retro Superhero Movie: The Incredibles
Runner-Up: The Phantom

Best Animated Superhero Movie: Vampire Hunter D
Runner-Up: Batman: Mask of the Phantasm

Best TV Superhero Series: Alias... okay, I know... I enjoyed Lois and Clark a lot in the middle seasons.
Runner Up: Birds of Prey

Movie I Watched Having Never Read The Comic Book That I Quite Liked But Everyone Else in the Universe Seemed To Hate: Mystery Men!
Runner Up: Daredevil! JUDGE DREDD!!!

Best Introduction of a Character: Skeletor!!!

Best Line In An Otherwise Crappy Movie: "IF YOU WILL NOT TELL ME, I WILL HURT PEOPLE!!!"

Worst Picture: Steel... you thought I was going to say Batman and Robin, didn't you?
Runner-Up: Forest Gump... what? He was a superhero? Didn't you see the movie?

Worst Actor (Hero): Not Sly Stallone for Judge Dredd!
Runner-Up: Not Dolph Lundgren for The Punisher

Worst Actor/Actress (Villain): Sharon Stone - Clayface (yes, she was Clayface, you can not convince me otherwise).
Runner-Up: Faye Dunaway - Selena in Supergirl .... correction, Brenda Vaccaro as Bianca in Supergirl... what the hell did her character even do!?

Worst Musical Score: Danny Elfman - Spider-Man I

Worst Direction: Sam Raimi - Spiderman 2
Runner-Up: Whoever did Fantastic Four and wasn't the Barbershop guy.

Worst TV 'Superhero' Series EVER EVER EVER - I don't really watch superhero TV... so... West Wing.

Worst casting mistake ever: Halle Berry PERIOD

Most criminal misuse of talent: Bruce Lee, The Green Hornet TV series.

This was a shitty list. This is not definitive by any means. It is 5 in the morning!

In Catwoman, Sharon Stone's character overdoses on beauty cream and in result becomes invincible. The movie ends with an open ended fate for her that might suggest she will become Clayface in a sequel. At the moment, I consider her Clayface because otherwise the whole movie has no redeeming value, but if Clayface (albeit a ghey interpretation) is in it, then it wasn't a complete waste of my time.

My list was supposed to be something everyone copy and pastes and does themselves. Bleh, I'm too lazy to redo mine anyway. Superhero movies are whack.